Personal tools

Discussing An Interesting Idea From The Community: Linking Behavior To Health Premiums

by Fard Johnmar last modified Jan 23, 2008 06:13 PM

A member of the ChangeNow4Heatlh online community suggests that one way to improve health while reducing costs is to link insurance premiums to behavior.

A number of surveys indicate that Americans are concerned about the cost of healthcare, but also think people should pay higher insurance premiums if they engage in unhealthy behaviors.  For example, a 2005 WSJ/Harris Interactive poll indicates that the “majority of Americans say smokers and those who don't wear seat belts should pay different levels of insurance premiums, co-payments or deductibles.” 

Now, some employers are taking this sentiment to the next level.  According to the Financial Times, supermarket giant Safeway “will offer its employees discounts on their health insurance if they participate in a service that tracks the nutritional quality of the food they buy at its stores.”  Humana, the sponsor of the ChangeNow4Health campaign, is also leading the charge by “offering lower health premiums to employees who pursue healthy lifestyles.” 

This is certainly an interesting concept.  After all, it makes a lot of sense to encourage healthy behaviors by intervening directly at the source of many bad habits: the supermarket.  Of course, if this idea were to be rolled out more broadly, one would have to account for variations in the US population, especially geographic.  For some (especially those in poor neighborhoods), it’s very difficult to eat healthy because they do not have access to wholesome foods, including fresh fruits and veggies. 

Overall, however, the Safeway initiative is certainly intriguing.  Thanks to “Kim the Consumer” for suggesting this idea.  I’d love to hear what you think.

Trackbacks

Trackback this post

del.icio.us!
Document Actions

Linking behavior to premiums

Posted by at Jan 24, 2008 03:15 PM
I agree with the concept however, I think in reality it would be too intrusive and costly to administer. You can accomplish the same result by designing the health plan to reward or punish insureds by the results of their behavior. Offer a high deductible plan. By doing so you you are injecting some incentive to the consumer to avoid behavior that will likely result in money out of their pocket. Americans should have the freedom to behave as they please as long as it's legal however, at the same time all the rest of us should not have to pay for their poor decisions. Health insurance has got to back to a point where it is doing what insurance is supposed to do. That is preventing a catastrophic loss. Stressing catastrophic. If you have claims you should have to pay them. The people who use the system pay.

Another story on the Safeway Initiative

Posted by Clive Riddle at Jan 25, 2008 04:40 PM
Here's a summary and a link to another recent story on the Safeway initiative:

Hearty premium plan for healthy workers
US shop workers could find their health insurance premiums being linked to their food-buying habits, if a supermarket initiative wins acceptance. Safeway, which operates over 1,700 supermarkets across the the country, says it plans to offer its employees discounts on their health insurance if they participate in a service that tracks the nutritional quality of the food they buy at its stores. The move is part of a wider push by leading employers - including Kellogg, Humana and Pitney Bowes to offer lower health premiums to employees who pursue healthy lifestyles.

MSNBC, January 20, 2008
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/22758788/
Contact    Site map    Privacy Policy
© 2008 Developed by Humana to create an ongoing dialogue to reform health care.